Sunday, November 22, 2026

Short-form Content Is Harmful For Your Kids! AI, Children's Mental Health ft Ipsitaa & Dr Sid

Short-form Content Is Harmful For Your Kids! AI, Children's Mental Health ft Ipsitaa & Dr Sid

Author Name:Soha Ali Khan

Youtube Channel Url:https://www.youtube.com/@SohaAliKhanP

Youtube Video URL:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4SihflmCE_A





Title: Short-form Content Is Harmful For Your Kids! AI, Children's Mental Health ft Ipsitaa & Dr Sid

Author Name: Soha Ali Khan

Description: ALL ABOUT HER with Soha Ali Khan ft. Ipsitaa Khullar & Dr. Sid Warrier | Human Behaviour, Decision-Making, Dopamine, AI & The Science of Art

Why do we behave the way we do? Are our decisions truly our own, or are they driven by emotions, habits and unconscious patterns? Is technology changing the way our brains function? Can art and music actually influence our behaviour, improve our well-being and even shape society?

The human brain is perhaps the most fascinating and complex organ in our body. It influences everything we do from the decisions we make and the emotions we experience to the habits we develop, the relationships we build and the way we perceive the world. But how much do we really understand about why we think, feel and behave the way we do?

In this episode of All About Her, I sit down with behavioural scientist and independent artist Ipsitaa Khullar, along with neurologist Dr. Sid Warrier, for a fascinating, science-backed conversation about the human brain, behavioural science, decision-making and the influence of art on our lives.

Ipsitaa brings together two fascinating worlds behavioural science and music. A graduate of Yale University and the London School of Economics, she shares her perspective on how human behaviour is shaped by emotions, identity, culture and storytelling. We also explore her decision to pursue music full-time, her latest work, and why she believes art can be a powerful medium for inspiring social change.

With Dr. Sid Warrier, we unpack the science behind how our brains work, why we make irrational decisions, whether our gut instincts can be trusted, and how emotions influence our choices. We also explore the difference between logic and emotion in decision-making, why saying no can be so difficult, and the psychology behind people-pleasing.

We then get into the impact of technology on the modern brain from shrinking attention spans and digital addiction to AI’s influence on creativity, critical thinking and the way we make decisions. Is technology actually rewiring our brains? Are screens harmful for children? And could AI fundamentally change the future of human creativity?

The conversation also explores dopamine, why we keep repeating unhealthy habits, whether we truly have free will, and how much of our personality is shaped by biology versus our environment and experiences.

And finally, we explore one of the most fascinating intersections of science and creativity: Can art heal the brain? We discuss the science behind music, art therapy, brain development, chronic stress, songwriting and how creative expression can influence individuals, communities and society at large.

Whether you’re curious about why you make certain decisions, trying to understand your habits, concerned about the impact of technology on the next generation, or simply fascinated by the human brain, this episode offers a fresh perspective on what makes us human.

Because understanding the brain isn’t just about understanding an organ. It’s about understanding ourselves.

DISCLAIMER: This episode is intended for educational and awareness purposes. The views and experiences shared are for informational purposes and should not be considered a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. Always consult a qualified healthcare professional for individual medical guidance.

#AllAboutHer #SohaAliKhan #IpsitaaKhullar #DrSidWarrier #BehaviouralScience #HumanBehaviour #Neuroscience #BrainHealth #DecisionMaking #AttentionSpan #BrainDevelopment #Stress #HumanPsychology #WomensWellness #Podcast

📍 Whoppl Studios

————————————————————-

0:00 - Upcoming
2:14 - Introduction
3:00 - Meet Ipsitaa Khullar
3:46 - Meet Dr. Sid Warrier
4:33 - The Biggest Decision You Regret
8:06 - The Most Common Decision-Making Mistake
10:49 - Do We Decide With Logic or Emotions?
12:56 - Is Your Gut Instinct Really Trustworthy?
18:14 - Choosing Music Over a Conventional Career
24:06 - Can Art Really Change Our Lives?
29:51 - Why Is Saying No So Difficult? The Psychology of People-Pleasing
38:42 - AI & Technology: Are They Changing How We Make Decisions?
42:52 - Are Screens and Technology Harmful for Children?
49:02 - Does Ipsitaa Use AI to Create Music?
52:07 - Is AI Threatening Human Creativity and Art?
57:34 - Ninna’s Questions
1:00:55 - Can Chronic Stress Change Your Brain?
1:05:59 - Is Art Good for Your Brain? The Science of Music
1:10:20 - Ipsitaa on the Art of Songwriting
1:17:56 - Can Art and Music Change Society?
1:21:36 - How Does Art Influence Gender Perceptions and Behaviour?
1:26:58 - Do Male and Female Brains Function Differently?
1:31:10 - How to Recognise Your Own Bad Decision-Making Patterns
1:34:26 - Dr. Sid’s One Habit for Better Brain Health
1:44:08 - The One Decision We’re Proud of Making
1:49:17 - Outro

————————————————————————-

Produced By: Soha Ali Khan
Creative Producer & Writer: Bhumika Jethwa
Assistant DOP: Jimit Sondagar
Post-Producer & Editor: Yash Patel

Transcript:
(00:02) I almost killed myself recently. So smart people also make bad decisions [music] >> sometimes exclusively >> or even just as a woman my gut has saved me. >> I think from a very very young age girls have had to build that intuition simply for safety. >> Always listen to your mom. >> Yeah. Just listen to my mom for sure.
(00:18) >> Yeah. >> Yeah. Cuz she watches this podcast. [laughter] >> The strongest tool is self-awareness. >> Look at the beauty industry. We play to women's insecurities and insecurities in general and then you are forced into buying something. Please guys, stop talking to Chad GPT like it's your therapist. It's not.
(00:34) So you are >> basically [music] talking to a company that can use your data to sell you stuff. Cigarettes were so common. People were smoking on planes, hospitals, and now it seems absurd. I [music] truly believe that in 20 years that is how we will talk about when it comes to social media for children.
(00:50) Every time you scroll, especially if you're watching short form videos, you are going to get a new dopamine spike every [music] 8 to 10 seconds. That has its own damage. But every hour of peace that you get when your kid is on the iPad, I believe that you'll have to pay for it multiffold later. >> What is more worrying to me is as an artist, if I start designing for attention spans [music] versus designing for meaning.
(01:11) >> This is especially true in art because all art comes from depth and [music] suffering in some way and AI cannot suffer and so it cannot really create art. It can give you the impression of art. >> Statistics can change minds and that's what we try with social sciences. But stories [music] change hearts. >> That is why music is like a drug.
(01:28) Imagine the kind of dopamine hit that you get. >> Yeah, >> it is ecstasy. I think the same chemical composition as what an ecstasy [music] pill would be because it's adrenaline, dopamine, serotonin. But somehow when it comes to mental things, we believe that all failure is is final. >> There's enough pain as a woman you have to endure anyway.
(01:49) We almost glamorize the battle. We want what we can't have and but like I'll be better. I'll do more. Was there anything you want to say about the female brain being more superior? Because I prompted you so many times [laughter] >> and you have not. >> I I was saving it for the Yes. of course. >> I'll just make that check out to doctor.
(02:04) [laughter] [music] >> So you made about 35,000 decisions today. what to wear, whether to reply K or okay, whether to actually go to the gym. Most of them you don't even remember making. We form first impressions in seconds, develop habits without noticing, remember certain moments for years, really hold on to them, forget others almost instantly, and we react emotionally before we've had the chance to think logically.
(02:41) So, it makes you wonder how much of our behavior is actually a conscious choice. Hello and welcome to All About Her. And today we're bringing together two unique perspectives, science and art, to explore one of the biggest questions of all. Why do we behave the way we do? And what truly shapes the human experience.
(03:00) So our first guest wears two very different hats, that of a behavioral scientist and an artist. A graduate of Yale University and the London School of Economics. like me. She spent years studying what shapes human behavior and applying those insights to solve realworld challenges. Alongside her work in behavioral science, she's also a singer songwriter, composer, and storyteller.
(03:24) Using art, I think, as a powerful medium to inspire conversation and social change. So, please join me in welcoming Ipsitaka. >> Thank you so much for having me. So, >> I'm very excited to have this conversation. >> I have admired you for years. I just want to put it out there. Yeah. >> How many years? 12 or 13 [laughter] >> not too many >> when I became aware of your work and also LSC representative.
(03:45) So >> yeah, >> thank you. And we also have joining us India's leading neurologist who has made it one of India's leading he's like okay >> huh >> okay where do you want to put yourself in the middle on the top >> oneoff would be my aim yes >> okay one of India's leading neurologists who has made it his mission to make neuroscience accessible beyond hospitals and classrooms a practicing neurologist educator public speaker Dr.
(04:09) Ed warrior combines medicine, neuroscience, and psychology to help people better understand their brains, their behavior, and themselves. Through his clinical work and public education, he has brought conversations around brain health, mental well-being, and human behavior into the mainstream, making complex science relatable and practical for millions of us.
(04:29) We're delighted to welcome Dr. Seora. >> Thank you so much for having me. >> Thank you so much. I'm excited because this conversation is very exciting for me understanding why we do the things that we do and how much of us is controllable, reformable, conditionable, bad decisions, gut instinct. Like I I don't think we think about this a lot.
(04:53) Um and I don't know perhaps people overthink it as well. So we're just going to think about it just the right amount after this conversation. And I thought I would ask you both um as an opening question perhaps a more recent decision you've made that you have regretted. Like for me, I ate too many cherries last night.
(05:10) >> Okay. >> And um for various [laughter] reasons, I regret that. >> No, fair enough. >> Should I start? >> Yeah. Yeah, please go. >> I almost killed myself recently. >> Oh, no. That is far worse than eating [laughter] too many cherries. >> Yeah. Um I turns out I had typhoid but the whole time I thought I had a viral infection. I was really sick.
(05:31) Um I had a super high fever that was refusing to come down for like 4 days. My mom's a doctor. I didn't listen to her. She kept saying >> she kept saying I was at home in Chandigar at the time preparing for a show that I was putting together. She's like just take some antibiotics. But also she says that for everything and that's part of the reason why we have antibiotic resistance, right? So my belief system was no I already have it.
(05:51) I need to cure my body of all of this and keep my gut flora healthy. So, no, I'm not going to just have an antibiotic. I'm pretty sure it's a viral. >> And uh four days go by, we get the blood work done and then it takes 3 days for the culture to come back. But turns out by that time the salmonella had spread like crazy and then it was another challenge because the heaviest doses of the most potent drugs were not working on me.
(06:17) So then I was on drips for like three weeks. Uh, so if I had started antibiotics earlier, maybe that smaller level of infection in my body could have been cured. >> My god. Is that why we pushed this podcast a little bit? [laughter] You said I have 102 fever or something. >> Oh no, that was it. Just took me a while to recover. My god. >> Yeah, because >> I'm good now.
(06:35) >> Yeah, thank God. >> Yes, thank God. [laughter] And yeah, I think our 3 days of fever blood test is >> a good thing to do. >> No doctor. >> And typhoid can be notorious for just sticking around in the body and causing all these chronic pains. I'm so glad that you're out of it. >> Thank you.
(06:49) And always listen to your mom. Always listen to your mom. [laughter] >> She depending on who your mom is and Yeah. Just listen to my mom for sure. >> Yeah. [laughter] >> Yeah. Cuz she watches this podcast. >> What about you? Um so it's a very silly thing to admit to being a doctor but um I have been training pretty intensely for the last one or two months and I started getting this niggling back pain which I sore was just muscle tightness whatever and um my instructor kept telling me that okay you should stretch properly stretch properly and I thought
(07:23) I was but turns out that I completely misunderstood what stretching actually means if you're working out intensely. >> So, it's not a 5 minute cool down. It's a 30 40 minute proper stretch. >> But who's doing that? >> Exactly. >> Who's doing that? >> And I really regretted not doing it because um I was actually bedridden for almost 3 days because of severe severe back pain.
(07:50) And I thought that I had a nerve compression. Being a neurologist, I went into a full spiral. But it turns out that it was just severe hamstring tightness and I needed like a lot of recovery time for that. >> So yes, I didn't stretch. Bad decision. Um should know better. >> So now we're in in better places. But I I want to ask a more general question in terms of what you think I um why is it that people make decision-makings that go wrong? Like the most common decision-making mistakes that you find, not the three of us, but people generally make. Yeah, there are many,
(08:21) but the one that takes me by surprise every time is this concept of mis wanting. So, this is a term coined by a psychologist at Harvard, a professor called Daniel Gilbert along with one of his colleagues. And they basically studied that people think they know what they want because they think it will make them feel happy, but then when they get that, they don't report being as happy as they thought they would be.
(08:44) >> Um, and it goes in both directions. Sometimes something bad happens to us and we think that it's going to debilitate and like destroy our lives. >> But we actually have another concept called immune neglect that we >> we are much stronger at dealing with uh really challenging situations than we give ourselves credit for.
(09:02) So the con overall concept of mis wanting is really interesting because it basically signals that we're really bad at what we call affective forecasting. So when you ask someone, let's say tomorrow morning I want to give you 10,000 rupees because you're such a great human being and you don't owe me anything back for that.
(09:17) >> How happy do you think you'll be on a scale of 0 to 10? Zero being like not happy at all, 10 being extremely happy. Maybe someone will say seven, >> right? >> The next morning I go to their house, I give them the money and then I'm like, how happy are you now? They might say four or they might say nine. >> And the idea is that we don't know what makes us happy.
(09:37) And that that really takes me by surprise and I go through it myself as well even after knowing what 108 cognitive biases exist in the world. It's not that you can overcome them, right? In fact, there's a fallacy for that. My mentor at E, Lorie Santos, worked on this and she called it the G.I. Joe fallacy. >> So, I don't know this cartoon.
(09:54) It's from the 80s. >> I know. >> You know, GI Joe. Yeah. >> Super [laughter] fun. Sorry, just a little bit. >> Yeah, I just got reminded of >> I didn't grow up watching it. But apparently at the end it says knowing is half the battle. But they say that no, that's not true for behavioral science. Knowing is not even a tenth the battle.
(10:14) You have to actively work yourself out of these cognitive biases and heruristics. >> Um but just to close the loop because I hate to just be morose as a person. Uh when you don't know what you want, it's also a function of social comparison. So, one really quick way to fix it is stop comparing yourself to other people who have more.
(10:29) >> Instead, perhaps if you have to compare, compare with people who have less because it'll >> instantly make you feel gratitude. >> Um, social connection is a buffer for this and journaling, mindfulness, meditation are all buffers for uh kind of grounding yourself in the reality of how far you've come from where.
(10:47) Of course. >> Yes. >> Uh, a couple of things that also made me think was that why do we make certain decisions when you're saying with perhaps we prioritize short-term over long-term and therefore we're unhappy sometimes with the result. Uh, and I thought I would ask you uh Dr. Wario said I feel like I >> you can call me safe.
(11:06) >> Okay. Thanks. Um, that when we make a decision, >> are we using logic? Are we using emotional? Are we fundamentally emotional reactive people pretending to be logical and emotion kicks in first >> or are we rational people and is there a difference between men and women when it comes to decision? That last googly was just [laughter] >> Yeah.
(11:32) So, we would love to be rational, right? We would love to think of ourselves as rational beings. But, um, what most evidence points to is that our decisions are made from an emotional space and that decision is being sent forward into our rational brain to do what it does best, which is to rationalize. >> Yeah.
(11:53) So suppose if there's an ice cream in front of me and I decide >> to eat it, that decision is already made from my emotional center. That decision is sent to my evolved brain which is the prefrontal cortex. Now my prefrontal cortex has the job of trying to find a narrative that will allow me to do what I've already decided to do. >> So make an excuse for >> make an excuse for it. Right.
(12:13) >> Right now there is a way out of it. Your prefrontal cortex can say no. It has veto power. But this is a exercisebuilt response. You have to keep practicing it. So a weak prefrontal cortex will not have veto power. And so the emotional brain is deciding >> but from the outside you can't tell, >> right? >> Because it looks like a reasonable person deciding but it's coming from an emotional brain, >> right? >> Yeah.
(12:40) >> So smart people also make bad decisions >> sometimes exclusively. [laughter] >> Um >> because they're smart in making the stories that can justify their emotions. So they're just better able to justify bad decisions and it seems like there's a very compelling reason as to why they're doing what they're doing.
(12:57) >> What about things like gut instinct? Because a lot of people say listen to your gut. A lot of people say, >> you know, don't react, respond. >> And I wanted to ask you whether there is one way of going about it. Is it that your gut protects you and leads you to doing the right thing or is that something that we should ignore? Um, I think I have different answers as a behavioral scientist and then just as an artist.
(13:21) >> As an artist, my gut has saved me always. Or even just as a woman, my gut has saved me. A lot of times I'm walking down an alleyway >> and I also went to school in New Haven, not really the safest [laughter] the safest city in the US. Um, or even in my years in London, I there was something within me that just told me without any evidence ahead, don't take this route.
(13:44) take a draft instead and only when I have taken that later have I found out what was going on there and those things are almost spiritual and I do also feel like women's intuition you you asked a gender based difference question >> um I don't know >> the science behind it and I don't think many scientists are studying it yet it's kind of categorized as woowoo and spiritual which is why I said my answer is different as an artist because I tap into that more to help generate creativity but in behavioral science I can't at least I've not come across also
(14:12) studied research that either says follow your gut or says don't. In fact, most of the times we would say don't because to to what Dr. Sid was just saying, >> system one thinking is that really fast quick thinking um which is emotional which makes us biased which makes us not the most >> empathetic sometimes and system two is more of the logical brain that it has to expend a lot of energy to make the right decision.
(14:40) Um and in today's age when uh you know you were talking about practicing overriding the amygdala using the prefrontal cortex, we're not doing that anymore. We are constantly >> on autopilot. >> Yes. >> Um and so in that >> from a desentered place, I don't think your gut will always be right. But from an aligned place of uh years of you know or ancestors guiding you or whatever you believe in or god guiding you I don't want to deny that as a scientist either because it has saved me so many times.
(15:09) >> Wow. Do you buy into like an a woman's intuition? >> 100% I buy into intuition as a whole. Um because for me the way that I >> first about intuition as a whole and then tell me about women's intuition. >> Absolutely I will. And I think there is a reason why women's intuition is uh powerful in the way that it is.
(15:28) Um because essentially there is a evolved brain and a emotional brain or the limbic brain. >> For me anything below the evolved brain is all part of one system. So I would include the gut in that quite literally everything from your uh brain stem, spinal cord, uh including your gut, neurons, everything is part of one system that is constantly processing information.
(15:56) >> We are only given access to around 3 to 7% of what our body is currently receiving >> in terms of information. So right now I'm looking at you two but my brain is receiving information from whatever is happening in the rest of the room. I'm not processing it consciously but if from my peripheral vision I spot something that feels dangerous to me >> I will start feeling a sense of something is off.
(16:23) >> I hope you don't. >> I [laughter] I hope so too. >> It's a safe space. >> But that is what intuition is. >> Yeah. And the more my um nervous system has been trained to pick up on those things, the better my intuition is >> in the positive way. That is what art is, >> right? Like you pick up on things and it gets processed at a level that is below our conscious and then it just pops up like a like a water bubble >> and then we become aware of it in our conscious brain.
(16:49) >> Right? So the more professionally uh evolved you are as an artist, you are actually training your subconscious brain or your intuition to do all the heavy lifting, >> right? >> Because that part of your nervous system is so much more capable. >> Yeah. >> Right. It is like 100,000x more powerful as a processor.
(17:06) >> Yeah. >> Because your prefrontal cortex will get tired very quickly. >> If I ask you to look at a spot for 5 minutes, you'll just get tired. >> But your subconscious brain can do that. >> Yeah. So that is the reason why you should trust your intuition but you should also train your intuition >> because it may not always be right.
(17:24) >> So I always think of it as a car and a driver. >> So the car has a very powerful engine >> but you still need to put your hand on the steering wheel. >> Mhm. >> So if your prefrontal cortex can drive >> and you allow your intuition to give that motivation or direction then you can be really powerful. M >> I think women can access that more because I think they've been training their intuition for a much longer time simply because they need to >> because safety >> for safety absolutely there's no getting around that. I think from a very very
(17:58) young age girls have had to build that intuition simply for safety and there is no greater force to train someone's intuition than person survival instinct. >> Absolutely. >> Yeah. >> That's fascinating. I'll get into that a little bit more. Um, but since we're speaking about decisions, I wanted to ask you, um, a lot of people already know your trajectory in terms of the fact that you went to Yale, you went to LSE, and then in the last six years, >> in fact, I think when you were at LSE, you came out with a music video.
(18:29) >> Um, >> that and then you, as we were discussing earlier, had a foot in both worlds and now you seem to have made a decision. Mh. Um, so certain decisions are quicker decisions and certain decisions are slower decisions. >> Um, why did you make that decision? What prompted it? And why was it a slow decision as opposed to a a hard and fast decision? >> Uh, I'm the first artist in my family.
(18:54) >> So that's why it was a very slow paced, slow burner type of a I'm going to sus this out for years and see if it's actually going to >> be worthwhile to pursue type of a situation. My dad is in the is retired now, but he's still working. My mom's a gynecologist. I have an older brother. Both of us were academically successful.
(19:13) >> I think again just thanks to my parents um jeans. [laughter] >> I'm sure a little bit to do with your effort. >> A little bit in some subjects more than others. And um basically what was expected of us was to study very hard, get as close to 100% as possible in every year, in every school that we were in.
(19:32) Every two years we were in a new school. >> Yeah. um and he was preparing for engineering entrance exams if he were to stay back in India. I think around the 11th grade he started thinking about going abroad. I had been fascinated with yield since I think 9th or 10th grade >> but I kept it within myself and I'd heard about the Ivy League in school and I just went home and I was like what is this and you know everybody knows Harvard and Stanford but I feel like back then even now not many people know the other Ivy Leagues and Stanford is not even an an Ivy League. Um but no
(20:00) anyway so I just became obsessed with Yel because kids there were really u good at performing arts >> and very inclined towards whichever subject they decided they wanted to do. If they were premed, then they were they could be a fascinating, amazing singer, but also preparing to be a doctor. >> And that was the norm.
(20:18) >> And I always felt like I was an outlier in every school I attended. And I was always told to pick my lane >> or, you know, there were limits. And still to this date, I find that to be a thing that happens a lot, like are you a singer, are you an actor, are you a behavioral scientist? >> Why can I not be all? >> Um, and so Yel felt like a space where you were allowed to be everything under the sun. Yeah.
(20:38) >> And so I became very obsessed with the idea of applying there. I always told myself I wasn't going to get in just to manage my expectations because the acceptance rate is like under 6%. >> But it's sensible to protect yourself. >> Yeah. [laughter] And I was >> expect the worst but hope for the best. >> Exactly.
(20:55) I think I live by that philosophy. Uh but my parents were very hard on both of us and they said you're either attending the best colleges in India. So with me I ended up mixing a stream. So the summer after 10th grade, my dad gifted me. >> So you're either attending or >> you're either attending the best colleges in India or you're getting into an Ivy League with full scholarship.
(21:12) We can't afford to send you to an Ivy League cuz they're both in the public service. >> Uh and that was the thing that both my brother and I were subjected to. >> So there was a lot of pressure to succeed. Uh luckily with God's grace, my brother went to Columbia with scholarship. I went to Yale. And obviously to your point, we worked really hard as well.
(21:31) Um, but I was saying that my dad gifted me this book some after 10th grade called thinking thinking fast and slow by Daniel Kman. You've of course you've heard about it and another one which is really dumb but it's called you are not so smart by David McCrainy. I call it very dumb because it's like pop psychology but it was so pivotal in like making me enamored by this field of behavioral economics.
(21:53) So I will be honest that was my first love. I grew up on stage. My mom enrolled me in katak when I was five. I was acting in plays when I was seven and I was singing before I could talk. My brother was singing as well but I never thought that I could pursue that as a career because that was never presented as an option. It was always like oh she does this on the side as hobbies and that was encouraged but >> uh there was no example around me of that being a choice that you could make.
(22:16) Uh yeah, sorry I'm all over the place but >> no but I think because your your journey speaks to many people I think especially in a cultural setting like India where there is parental pressure to >> pursue a certain career and that pressure affects us when we make any decision it is hard to negate that >> um and also the point that you said in America there is an educational system that fosters a sense of completeness of that you're not just studying one thing >> but um taking a slight step step back.
(22:46) I think what you said is very relatable about how every kid in India is forced to put themselves into boxes where even the idea of doing of picking science versus commerce versus art when they are in 10th standard is so silly if you think about it because in what world do you not need to know about commerce if you're a scientist or in what world would science not help if you're an art student? How is this so black and white and why are kids being asked to choose at an age where they should be in fact told to explore everything
(23:21) >> right so you being a musician who also likes behavioral u science um it's unfair if in India you are asked to just pick one and forget about the other >> so this actually leads to issues with identity people are people end up being lesser than who they could be >> and that's not Fair, >> right? >> Yeah, >> you're right.
(23:45) And especially when you're making that choice at such a young age, maybe, you know, you can choose to specialize >> a little later. >> You know, we forget that some of these children are 17, 16 when you make those choices and you exclude certain things and certain things you don't think go together at all like maths and music often do.
(24:00) >> And I know so many people who have embraced the both at at a university level and and beyond. >> And one thing um that I wanted to ask you about uh Sid was that art, how does art touch your life? because we know how it touches our lives. >> Um and >> the importance of art >> um the impact that art has had.
(24:21) >> Does that also resonate with you? >> Very much so. I think art has saved my life. Absolutely. So I grew up in a musical household as well. My mom is a karnatic teacher. Really? >> So I was trained in classical music for seven years when I was a kid and then I switched over to you know western music, guitar, all of that.
(24:39) So when I was in MBBS, I was part of the band. [laughter] Yes. Medical students also perform music. >> You get the time. >> Yeah. So in MBBS we we do get the time. And when I was doing my residency in KM, I remember uh in my first year residency, it was it was absolute chaos, right? It was a nightmare. Each student would get like 100 patients under them and you don't sleep for 3 days.
(25:03) >> And so at the end of a particularly bad week, I thought that I was going to quit. And one of my uh one of my juniors told me that um hey listen don't quit. What is it? What is something that you really like doing? And I said I like reading books. I like poetry. So she said why don't you just search if there are any poetry clubs around or any book clubs around and just take out half an hour just go out and get out of the hospital and >> you know be a part of something else.
(25:30) >> And I searched on Facebook. I found a poetry club nearby and I went there and it's been like 15 years. Those people are still my best friends. We used to meet every month. We would share a poem. We would give each other feedback. It grew up to be like almost 100 members after the next five years.
(25:45) We performed in Kalagura. So poetry and music has been a constant, you know, parallel throughout. >> Yeah. >> So even now I feel that when I'm creating content on YouTube, it's it's ultimately an artistic expression. Absolutely. >> Right. Like you have something to say, but how you say it presented >> makes all the difference, which is what art is. Yeah.
(26:04) >> So yes, it's been a big part of my life. >> Why is it that in India people put arts at the bottom and there's commerce and then there's >> misunderstanding. >> I don't think they understand. >> It's not that one has less value than the others in the world. >> No, >> it might have been the case from an economic standpoint years ago uh where as an artist perhaps you were never going to break a certain ceiling of income through just performing on stage.
(26:31) Right now the media space has grown so much. Um it's quite ironic that parents on the one hand wouldn't want their child to enter this industry but then are happy to take them to a concert of you know and pay a lot of money where you know so there is a dichotomy there and it's interesting I think these conversations are helpful as starting points >> and examples I think also of people who are successful of which now in the YouTube generation there are so many >> exactly and there's there have been advances as well in terms of I don't
(27:02) need a record label anymore I'm an independent an artist. I am writing my own music, >> getting it produced through a friend, >> and uploading it on my distributor's website, and it's going to be on the same platform as any massive record labels music is going to be. >> In fact, there's been a massive shift where artists are choosing and waiting out their remaining years in a label >> to turn independent to fully control their own artistry and creative expression.
(27:28) They don't have to be answerable to anyone's >> uh boxes. >> The Taylor Swift phenomenon, [laughter] right? Is that what's going on? >> Yeah. >> So, uh I think things are changing and I would just love for more parents to be accepting of their child participating in the arts. >> To your point, it is such a great source of stress relief, reducing your cortisol, boosting your dopamine, >> enhancing your social connectedness with other like-minded people who are joining.
(27:57) We are in a digital era where kids don't have friends in real life anymore. arts and social just earn which by the way they can earn a lot now through >> through this. So that's no longer that big a problem for like it's just a prioritization that happens like first you do sciences then you do commerce and then art is like if you don't get into anything else then you >> exactly and we really need to change that >> and that is changing >> it is changing uh I also think it's a reflection of what society needs >> right so if you look at it from social
(28:33) perspective um at a time when countries are developing you need more of engineers you need more of people who can actually build things and sure that's a very practical way of looking at it and That's where the money goes. What's interesting is that now with more and more technology, >> with more and more AI, a lot of these skills are being outsourced and what is missing is the humanities part.
(28:57) >> So people who take STEM, which is, you know, science, engineering, maths, they are lacking creativity, >> right? >> They are lacking lateral thinking. They don't know how to think out of the box and create new solutions. And that comes in arts. >> And that's the human edge that we have. the human edge. Exactly.
(29:15) But if your brain is a machine that can be trained, so if since childhood you've only been taught to solve equations and say that 1 plus 1 equals 2, you can never think about how 1 plus 1 could equal something else if you add something extra. >> Right? And that is what creativity is. That's what art is. >> Yeah. >> And today I think humanity is sort of waking up to the fact that okay, we really need to figure this stuff out because this is what makes life worth living.
(29:41) >> Yes. Yes. >> The arts, the happiness comes from self expression >> and if you don't get that, what's the point of having bridges? >> Yeah, absolutely. I want to explore art a little bit later. I want to talk come back to decisions a little bit because you talked about parental pressure >> and a lot of children >> I'm sure when you're young it's harder even to say no, but even adults have trouble saying no.
(30:07) Um and I again these questions are for the both of you and you can uh choose or fight over it or [laughter] rather I'll ask I'll ask you first because you talk about parental pressure. Is it firstly easier to say no than yes? In my experience it has um is it easier to say yes than no? In my experience it is. I'm also a people pleaser. I'll ask you why.
(30:27) And my add-on question is is it because I'm the third child because I feel I really and please feel free to debunk it but I feel like I can see child order psychology in our family one two and three and how we are the way we are >> and I think that all third children are born >> and not born become people pleasers >> just to be noticed.
(30:48) >> Interesting. >> So I'm the >> they're there. [laughter] >> Yeah. Thanks. >> I'm the second child. I'm the youngest in my family and I'm not a people pleaser. >> No. >> Um I the way I like to dissect this is individual forces that shape you, social forces that shape you and then environmental and cultural forces that shape you.
(31:08) So as an individual we can think about personality psychology to your point about being a yes man or yes woman. >> That will be a determinant of can you say no to people. Then socially it could be who are the influences in your life. For example, my mother is a tigress. I have heard her say no to people's faces left, right, and center her entire life.
(31:26) She knows how to put someone in their place, but also do it with such class and elegance that they're never offended. Um, so if I didn't have that mother, perhaps I would have been a yes person, right? So, and then culturally as a girl, uh, you know, in which era am I born? Digital society versus that, that's going to shape if I can say yes or no.
(31:47) Um, so there's no like >> I don't want to just give a black and white answer to this. Um, but I think that there's an art to saying no. >> A lot of times people are >> You just said yes. [laughter] >> People are manipulating you into saying yes as well. Right. There's social psychology around this. There are techniques. >> Give an example of how someone is manipulating you into saying yes.
(32:08) >> So there are two techniques. One is called uh door in the face and foot in the door. So foot in the door is if I get you to say yes to a small ask like hey your whoop looks really nice can I wear that I just want to see how it looks you're like yeah sure and then I'm like actually I really like it like can I take it for the day and then because you've let me wear it once >> so once you say yes to a small request you are more likely to say yes to a larger request why because everybody likes to be >> um consonant in their thinking you would
(32:39) like to believe that you're a good person who does not have cognitive dissonance which is the idea that you hold separate ideas at once which makes you uncomfortable. >> So it's also we were talking about meaning making and going to >> uh going to bed making sense of everything we did that day like yeah that made sense I did that because XYZ and I'm a good person everybody likes to >> yeah so it's a conscience clearing mechanism as well which someone can manipulate if they want to.
(33:04) Then the other is um >> the reverse of that. So if I get get you to say no to a very large request, >> then if I ask for something little, you're likely to say yes because you want to be a good person too. So people and marketers and advertisers are exploiting this all the time without us realizing. >> Tell me about marketers exploiting this.
(33:24) What do you mean? >> I mean, look at the beauty industry, >> right? There are we we play to women's insecurities and insecurities in general. um you will create a belief that you need to just try this is a trial pack for something and you know and then you are forced into buying something larger or in a Sephora or whatever.
(33:43) >> Uh they are trained to sell you a product by eating off of an insecurity that you have but also getting you to just like >> say yes to a smaller request first. >> Um but yeah >> what do you think? I um so it's interesting because we have a second child, third child and I'm I'm the older child >> and I am I I think I classify myself as a recovering people pleaser >> because I've been through that and I don't think it's about the seniority of the child.
(34:14) I think it's absolutely the environment that that particular child grows up in because my mom is a people pleaser. She I've always grown up seeing her making everyone happy and everybody loves her >> and typically mothers are they like to keep the peace and >> correct and so you kind of learn from those behaviors that this is the way to navigate through life and all of us learn different ways.
(34:37) So typically whenever you are anxious there is a fight or a flight response and there is a third response called fawning. M >> so fawning is basically when you are people pleasing in exchange for comfort safety liking >> right so it is a way of ensuring safety >> so is fighting so is flying away or running away >> right >> so each of us sort of picks one of these to be our core defense and sort of builds our personality around it slowly slowly as a child is growing >> and depending on whether that strategy works you will double down on it Right?
(35:13) >> So if I as a child have managed to go through school without too much of bullying simply by being nice and friendly to people if somebody's like oh can I take your water bottle like hi Lelay to the >> do >> that is a way of ensuring that okay this person and I will not have any issues and in my child brain that is >> you know en certained or sort of cemented that this is a good strategy for life and that sticks with you >> until you go to therapy and you realize Oh You know, this is what I do.
(35:44) I have no boundaries. >> Exactly. And then for all these personality strategies, >> it's great until it's great. >> No, but tell me like because just close the loop for people who are wondering why giving away a water bottle is leading them to therapy because they have no boundaries. >> So what is that rabbit hole that you're going down? >> So what happens is that you realize that it is a scam that you're playing on yourself.
(36:11) Essentially the scam is if I'm nice to you, you will be nice to me. What you realize as a people pleaser is that you are being nice to them and they have not taken up any obligation to be nice back to you. >> Yeah. >> Right. And so if you tolerate bad behavior >> thinking that they will tolerate bad behavior, they will not because their defense mechanisms are different.
(36:32) >> Right. >> And so you end up feeling betrayed, >> right? that oh when you behave badly for you but >> why not this is the typical graph that all people pleasers go through and then when they realize that >> hitting home >> oops [laughter] but it's a good journey to go on because once you realize that then you start understanding the value of boundary setting you realize that setting boundary is not being rude setting boundary is not pushing people away no one will leave you for setting a boundary if you have done it properly
(37:02) and in fact people become closer because If they love you, they have also been very confused by your behavior >> because you seem as if you're okay with everything, but you're secretly not okay with everything. >> So, just be clear. >> Just be clear. So, this is the healing arc that a people pleaser goes through.
(37:19) >> But give me a specific tool that I can use as someone who has had trouble saying no. How can I um change myself for lack of a better word? How can I um like a tool that will help me to start that process of building boundaries? The strongest tool is self-awareness because like I said a every person would make a decision in their emotional brain and justify in their prefrontal cortex.
(37:44) A people pleaser would have actually created that story that I am okay with everything >> right >> but are you >> right >> the day you accept that you know what this did bother me >> right >> and that bother while feeling is important enough for me to express everything will change. The problem is that people pleasers don't really accept that with themselves.
(38:07) The day they accept it, things change. Nothing else needs to be done. Otherwise, they're sensible people. >> Yes. >> They just have to accept this. >> I like you're saying them, but you're talking to me. Like you're >> I'm actually talking to myself, [laughter] >> right? But you're a reformed. You have >> recovering. >> Recovering. Okay.
(38:20) That's >> it's hard to get out of some habits, but yes. >> Is it like that? You're wild. Like an alcoholic. You're always an alcoholic. You're always a people pleaser. >> How many days have you been? [laughter] >> Yeah, I carry I carry that coin with me. >> 45 days. 45 Days of Saying No. Yes. >> But I'm glad you said yes to cover to the podcast.
(38:36) Anyway, >> that's a great topic for a book, by the way. Book title, 45 Days of Saying No. >> 45. There you go. >> Interesting. >> Okay, I want to come to technology because we talked about how that interferes with your sense of balance and then perhaps your ability to make decisions is taken out of your hands. I feel certainly and there's a whole generation there's like 500 million social media users and I'm not even making up that statistic.
(38:59) Um and in India you have I think the young are spending hours you know we had a session on digital detox with somebody and um we talked about the fact that 8 10 hours of the day are going just scrolling being on phones a lot of people are working on phones now >> then a lot of your decisions a I feel are being controlled by an algorithm or something else that's happening what are the dangers of that um so I I mean also because you're younger than us you take this one first. Closer to Jenzi.
(39:30) Firstly, how many decisions did you make today that an app actually made for you? And are you one of those people? >> I think I've been saved a little bit because I'm on the older side of Gen Z. Um, and I've had proximity to people who >> yeah, >> like for my first encounter with technology was when I was 2 years old, which is still young, but nowadays it's like >> the second you pop out.
(39:54) [laughter] Um, I don't let technology make decisions for me to the extent that I believe that to be true. Yeah. >> Right. Um, I think that I've always been really scared like I've been someone who's been scared of technology. Um, such as like Hey Siri when it first la Apple first launched that. I to this date have never had Siri on my phone.
(40:14) >> And what scares you about Hey Siri? >> The fact that it's always listening. It anyway is >> right. So that's why I say that it's kind of a story I'm telling myself that I have authorship over my choices and autonomy over my digital >> uh world. >> So you think >> exactly but at least it feels good to know that compared to the average user I am choosing differently >> because I hate the fact that it always listens.
(40:37) So I have predictive marketing off I have uh personalized ads off on all social media. So a lot of my friends will complain about remember we were just having that conversation and then I got this ad. I'm like, well, thank God that's not me. [laughter] >> To that extent, you at least feel like you're in a controlled digital environment.
(40:53) And I think this is also because I am a behavioral scientist that I try to control um or curate or design an architecture in my >> lived physical space that will propel me to have better behaviors and better habits. Right? So, if I want to eat healthy, I'm not going to keep cook in my snack drawer. Um, that's a really small example, but we forget that you can do that online.
(41:16) You can opt out of certain things. >> I do this with my child because children like having options, right? >> So, the idea is to give her everything that she chooses is healthy. So, you just put them all there. >> But, it does make choices for you on like there's Spotify will tell you what you should listen to.
(41:28) Netflix will tell you what you're going to like. >> Uh, the craziest is Uber and that one I can't hack myself out of. >> What do you mean? Uber will has such great pattern recognition and analysis of my past data that it knows that if it's a Wednesday and 12 p.m. she's headed to the gym. >> If it's Monday 7:00 p.m.
(41:44) she's going to her studio. >> So that'll be the first thing that pops up and it freaks me out, but it knows and I have opted into that and there's no way to opt out. So >> uh that's what I mean. It is anyway listening and it is anyway watching. >> Please guys stop talking to Chad GPT like it's your therapist. It's not. >> But it is very empathetic.
(42:01) I just want to say perhaps even more than my therapist, >> but it's the illusion of empathy. It's not >> it's just telling me what I want to hear. >> The makers are telling us that there is nothing, no legality surrounding this. So, you are >> basically talking to a company that can use your data to sell you stuff >> and you're giving them your most vulnerable information.
(42:21) Now, imagine how good of a customer target you become when you literally are telling them your emotional state, >> right? That is the ultimate goal of a marketer to know your emotional state so that they can sell you something because a vulnerable consumer is a great consumer. >> So I think just my takeaway is we can curate a safer uh digital environment just like we do in our physical environment but I don't hear many people talking about that. Yeah.
(42:44) >> No. And I will come back to you in terms of, you know, you referred to uh, you know, nutritional choices, >> but maybe you can expand on the environment at home a little bit, but before that I wanted to ask, you know, we we made a reference to the fact that children have been told many times no screens before the age of two.
(43:00) >> Um, after that, people make up their own rules. I think people now know this and try at least. But as you're saying, a lot of even from a young age, >> children are being exposed to technology. There's a lot of debate as to whether social media should be uh banned. Things being banned are not always the solution because children will find a way and it just makes it even more attractive.
(43:19) But the basic question is are we overstating or exaggerating um the impact of technology and technological use? Is it actually rewiring our brain? For example, the you know the constant swiping and the addiction of it. Is that a reality? >> 100%. it is. So every time you scroll, especially if you're watching short form videos, what is happening in the brain is that you're training your brain's reward center >> that you are going to get a new dopamine spike every 8 to 10 seconds.
(43:52) >> Right now this happening in a 2-year-old's brain, you are basically training that brain that this is reality. >> This is the frequency with which you can expect a dopamine spike. Now you compare that with any other form of reality, it will always seem boring because dopamine spikes are exciting and what is boring and what is exciting is relative.
(44:16) >> Yes. >> Right. So if you train a baby brain to expect that many dopamine spikes at that frequency, that kid is not going to be able to pay attention to anything which is less stimulating. right now. This will have unforeseen consequences. The truth is that we haven't seen what it can do in the next 10, 15 years.
(44:40) And I keep going back to a time maybe 50, 60 years ago when cigarettes were so common, right? Like people were smoking on planes, people were smoking in operation theaters, >> hospitals, >> hospitals, right? And now it seems absurd. I truly believe that in 20 years that is how we will talk about when it comes to social media for children >> especially short form content.
(45:02) I'm not saying screens are bad overall but short form content does a lot of harm to your brain's dopamine network and that is the network through which you are motivated. You find long-term pleasure as well as short-term pleasure. >> Um your basic attention networks come from there. Yeah, >> if you screw that up, you can imagine what kind of problems those kids will have.
(45:24) >> Tell us why should we imagine? >> It's basically um everything that you think about when you hear the term ADHD. >> Yeah, >> that is attention deficit hyperactive disorder. Now ADHD is a genetic problem, right? So ADHD kids are born with those genes and they get triggered from environmental stresses.
(45:47) But you don't need to have ADHD for a kid to have ADHD symptoms. >> So ADHD symptoms is executive dysfunction. So you have a prefrontal cortex that is simply not able to say no. >> Right? >> So when there's a possibility of a dopamine spike, you need an adult brain or a you know controlled brain to say no, I don't need that dopamine spike.
(46:06) But if you're training the kid from childhood, >> but adult brains also can't say >> correct. And I mean I'm sticking with them. To be very honest, >> to be very honest, I don't make too much of a difference between an adult brain and a child brain. >> I think that there is some difference in the potential, >> but the behavior can sometimes be really similar, >> right? >> But I I have kids who come to my clinic.
(46:27) Um sometimes the parent is the patient and the kid is just with them >> and they are buried in their iPad. >> Yeah. >> And you take the iPad out for a second and they are balling. They they are uncontrollable. And as soon as you put the iPad back, they're silent. their eyes are just glued on >> which is why I understand how it is you know for many parents it's that reprieve that they get if you're multitasking um and I also understand for a lot of people who are working very hard when they come home especially close to
(46:56) bedtime and which is why you're doing all of that screen time before you sleep and then it might be affecting your sleep >> but people feel like we've worked really hard so we want to come back and we want to binge watch and we want to just go through reals on our phones so how can they >> not do that >> I would still draw a difference between uh adults coming home and relaxing with 1 hour of uh Instagram scrolling.
(47:16) I'm not saying that is super healthy. That has its own damage. But >> every hour of peace that you get when your kid is on the iPad, I believe that you'll have to pay for it multiffold later. >> Yeah. >> By the amount of you know problems that that kid will have later. That's a good point. >> So there has to be some sort of um coming back from it.
(47:36) I think Australia has already done a lot of steps in this direction. No social media for kids less than 16. >> Yes, >> I believe that that should be the norm in all countries. >> Because short form content is a problem. If you want to use kids iPads for digital uh studying, if they want to watch 30-inute videos, go for it. >> I don't think television is that harmful.
(47:58) I don't think long form videos are that harmful. But short form content is harmful because it trains your brain to expect reality to be different than what it is. And as a neurologist before I come to you Sitha, >> how many hours would you put on that in terms of screen time? >> Unfortunately, we don't have any data on this much is safe and this much is not because it is so subjective.
(48:20) Um because >> so watch out for signs perhaps like if your child is having an inability to focus or an inability to emotionally regulate themselves or obviously if they're missing out on peer interaction and human contact then you know these are things >> it's also to be taken in the context of what else is happening in that child's life.
(48:39) Is that child getting enough of playground time? Are they are they playing with other kids enough? Are they getting other life experiences? >> Yes. If so, then their brain is more capable of absorbing this and not being harmed by it. >> But a kid who is deprived of all of that and only is getting this, even a small amount of screen time could be harmful, >> right? >> It's why it's difficult to put an hour on it.
(49:01) >> Sure. Um, as an artist in a world that is increasingly becoming about >> 8second reels, >> how do you adapt your art >> um to to suit that? No, in fact, I feel like I missed the era of six minute songs. Yeah, not even just three. All my songs are over two and a half minutes long. >> Uh the most recent one is almost four.
(49:24) And I'm asking to meet up with my coarissist to actually add another bridge to one of the next releases, which is already a 4-minute song. So, that's going to be almost a 5-minute song. And that's not to just be like a rebel like ah no it's because I I crave that music and I crave the completion of the storytelling.
(49:44) >> It requires every art form requires a certain amount of time frame and window to justify what the characters are going through whether it's a movie or a TV show. And it really breaks my heart that recently I I heard that in Hollywood they are and it's going to happen here as well then as a result they are now creating shows where the story line keeps repeating the dialogues keep repeating because they are expecting the users and audience to be on their phones >> while while having the show on which is the sad reality.
(50:11) >> They really have to underline things. >> They have to repeat things. They're dumbing things down. No one's watching out for Easter eggs. No one's watching out for oh character development. they have to be like bombarded with audiovisisual cues of the same thing again and again because half the time they're on their phones.
(50:26) It breaks that that is more concerning than shorter attention spans which is that the attention spans this is not going to change right like when photography came it changed painting >> right >> uh when the television came sorry it changed cinema >> uh when streaming came it changed audio from purchasing CDs to now having everything on your fingertips.
(50:45) So this is not going to change. What is more worrying to me is as an artist if I start designing for attention spans >> versus designing for meaning. If I want to retain my authenticity, then I feel like I have to go against the grain. And in fact, ironically, that's how you'll stand out >> because everybody is designing for that 8-second hook loop.
(51:04) >> But it's content. >> You know, it's tough. >> It's really tough. And I I'm nowhere yet. Like I'm still at my early stages of being an artist, so I cannot claim to have done it. But I do want to say that like attention can be rented. Uh but meaning is is owned. Yeah. you know uh so I think we all need to focus on making sure that we are layering our craft with meaning being truthful in what we're trying to say and what stories we're trying to tell and people will come I don't like the reverse engineering of I think the audience
(51:35) wants is this is what the jenzi want and then you create that and then it doesn't fly with the jenzi [laughter] >> and then when they're protesting and they're telling you what they want then suddenly you don't want to listen so uh we need to do away >> with all of this these are just we like to intellectualize things but I think I keep coming back to being truthful and honest and making sure things are meaningful.
(51:55) >> Yeah, I think me first. I do think that that you know and you know you refer to AI as well and that if you're able to hold on to your authenticity and sometimes it'll be challenged and you have to and you have to see through that >> which leads me to ask you about AI >> um like many technological advances and you've referred to some of them uh they have been sort of technological advancements or inventions or >> you know I feel like with AI it's something else entirely it's not just something new >> um it's just something it's going to
(52:27) change the world in a way that it hasn't been changed for a very long time. >> Um, again, humans tend to it might have been there's lots of wonderful things about AI, >> but we tend to sort of not be able to draw a balance. >> So, how do you view it? And also the question of Instagram and YouTube, which do you prefer? Because I see you're active on both.
(52:48) >> Yeah. >> Um, >> the audiences are different, attention spans are different. >> Which do you prefer? So for me it's always been YouTube because of the way that I like to teach. Um YouTube has more depth you simply because it has more time >> and I've seen the same audience behave differently on different platforms.
(53:06) When they are on Instagram they expect a certain kind of uh hook masala because they they are there for entertainment. Nobody's on Instagram to learn. >> Nobody's the the education has to be accidental. you have to teach them that's it otherwise everything is very emotiondriven whereas on YouTube um that same person would find a video and then be okay to sit down on a couch and actually just watch the whole 8 10 minute video or if it's a 25 minute video they might put it on a TV and then they might still be walking around doing
(53:42) stuff but their their attention is on it so people's behavior is different on different platforms and I definitely prefer YouTube because of the way that it allows for storytelling. Um the thing with AI though is that it when it first came we all thought that oh this is a platform that can give us a final product.
(54:05) >> Yeah. >> Whether it's uh a story, whether it's a essay, whether it's a song, whether it's a poem, it almost looked like magic that how can AI give us a final product? I think now it's been what 2 three years since the world has been messing with AI. Now people are realizing that just because it looks >> like the final product doesn't mean it is the final product.
(54:30) And the only way that you know whether something is solid or not is by putting pressure on it. >> And what companies are discovering is that whatever AI is building, it is not building from scratch. >> Because there is no scratch. AI is simply collecting yeah >> things from around the world putting it together in a way that it predicts you will like right >> and giving you the front of it >> right >> but if you press against it you'll find that there is no depth >> right >> this is especially true in art because all art comes from depth and suffering
(55:05) in some way and AI cannot suffer and so it cannot really create art it can give you the impression of art >> but this is also happening in code So code that is exclusively written by AI when companies are trying to build code on top of it, it crumbles and then they need humans to come in and fix it which takes so much more time and so now companies who have fired a lot of people are now slowly rehiring them back.
(55:34) Interesting, >> right? Because they realize that if you're building for long term, >> this will not work, >> right? If you only want to build it to show a website quickly and get um investors in, sure AI is great. But if you're truly building for something that can sustain 20 years, >> yes, >> can you trust this? >> Yes. >> So there was a friend of mine who compared AI uh content to film sets.
(55:56) >> And they said that it can look like a living room, but is it a living room? >> Right? Nobody can live there because at the end of the day, people have to go back to their real homes. That is what AI is at the moment. >> So it is so so important that people do what you are doing which is find authenticity >> and I believe that you are doing this because you have already >> started your art journey before AI has truly kicked in.
(56:23) >> But somebody who is 13 or 12 right now who is starting their music journey might realize that I can just put a prompt on Chad GBT and it can give me a music theme and I can showcase that as my art. lyrics and composition and everything >> and if that kid showcases that song as oh I created this did they though >> right >> and have their brains gone through the process of >> cognitive >> taking in information suffering through that frustration of not being able to put it exactly in the same way trying it out failing and then having that
(56:56) pleasure of when it finally clicks >> that is the journey that an artist goes through and that is essential >> yes >> if kids miss out on art and they think that the final product is the same as them being an artist. An entire generation will miss out on that cognitive learning. That is the real danger of AI.
(57:14) >> I think that I'm so grateful that AI is in my life now and I do use it extensively but I'm so grateful that it's in my life now in my 40s >> where I have a my brain was not dependent on it growing up. So I hopefully feel like it has developed a little bit and parts of it are working and functioning.
(57:31) Those neurons and sinapses are open. you referred to dopamine and dopamine hits uh and just again that creating a certain spike. >> You've also made a real on Instagram and we talk about Instagram and YouTube where you spoke about serotonin and what happens at 2 a.m. and not me. >> Yeah, >> I don't know about you.
(57:50) I'm asleep at 2 a.m. now and I have been >> I've changed my bedtime. I figure it works for me. So 11:00 I lights out. No social life as a result, but it's fine. Um, but there was a time when I did stay up till way past 2 >> and I figured that >> that's not the best time to make decisions. >> Yeah. >> About what you're eating. Certainly.
(58:11) >> Yeah. >> Um, who you're calling. >> Definitely. >> But we do this and I have a friend for every episode that we do, she asks a question. So, her question for the both of you was that is 2 a.m. a good time to call her ex-boyfriend? I won't take his name. And why is it not a good decision? Because I was telling you it's never a good decision to call him.
(58:34) >> That's true. But the 2 a.m. Why is 2 a.m. such a dangerous time? Is that um you from a neurochemical perspective? Um serotonin goes down with the sun. >> Yeah. >> And serotonin has a very unique role to play in the brain, which is it is a dopamine modulator. it. Think of serotonin as dopamine's elder brother.
(58:58) >> So dopamine is like this excited girl, >> right? >> She's like, "Oh, I want this. I want this. I want this. What's behind this door? What's what's what's to eat? What's to watch?" And serotonin is like the older sibling like beta, calm down, relax. Right now, what happens at night is serotonin goes down thinking everybody has to go to sleep.
(59:19) I don't have any responsibility. >> Right? If you're awake at 2:00 a.m., dopamine is up and she's walking around the house and there's no serotonin to keep check. So that is when you are more likely to give in to impulses because there is no or there is less self-regulation at that time. >> So you are more likely to binge watch.
(59:41) you're more likely to call somebody that you shouldn't or text somebody you shouldn't because these are all basic immediate pleasure giving uh actions, >> right? >> And that's why 2 a.m. is such a dangerous time. >> When you say dopamine is up, you mean there is a heightened chance of us seeking more dopamine? Not that we are operating on a >> a higher dopamine level at night time, otherwise we'd be so happy.
(1:00:05) >> Yes. No, we are not. We are chasing dopamine. >> We're chasing it, right? >> So, we are chasing. And the thing with dopamine is that it is a short acting molecule. So it will if you eat one chip >> that pleasure will disappear really fast. And the way that our brain interprets a dopamine spike is that when it is going up, we are very happy.
(1:00:23) But when it's coming down, even if it comes back down to baseline, we are a little sadder >> than what we were before. So a fall in dopamine levels is interpreted as oh no >> let me fix it >> by the next dopamine spike. Now if there is serotonin alongside it that up and down movement of dopamine gets modulated >> right >> but without serotonin it can be like a big roller coaster.
(1:00:49) >> So you want to keep binging >> right? >> So that's what happens >> that that's what that explains a lot. [laughter] Um I also want to touch on things like anxiety and stress because you know we were speaking in fact when the camera was off as well about how there's a lot of people living in cities now.
(1:01:07) Um we have more comfort as a result of that. Life seems maybe easier in many ways for a lot of people especially the younger generation. There's more options but anxiety and stress seem to be on the rise. But is there an actual impact on the functioning of the brain or the structure of the brain from anxiety and stress? >> It does unfortunately.
(1:01:28) So uh stress is any situation that your brain feels it is not in control of. Um to put it in a different way, it feels that it is under threat that something here is going to kill me. So your brain is pretty silly that way. It's very it's much it's very dramatic that the smallest thing that can go wrong it can take it to the uh ultimate outcome that oh no what will happen to me now >> and that is what stress is and the more stressed out you are the more your body's defense mechanisms kick in.
(1:01:58) So your cortisol levels will spike, all the muscles in your body will become tense, your jaw will get tightened. Um and so chronic stress will actually lead to longlasting impacts in the body. So all these things if they were only happening for a few seconds, your body can recover. But imagine that you've been in chronic stress for a month, a year, two years.
(1:02:21) Say somebody living in a household where there are constant fights. >> Yeah. >> Or an abusive relationship or just a lot of pressure about your job or any of that. Your body is living in constant threat. >> There are both physical and psychological effects of this. So physical would be things like migraine attacks, neck pain, back pain, jaw tightness, um constant negative thinking.
(1:02:48) This is because your amygdala is now hyperactive. It sees threats even when there are no threats. So somebody who is stressed out and their friend makes a small little joke on maybe some pimple on their face and they they would think that how dare you insult me, you don't respect me. They will hear things differently.
(1:03:03) So their reality has shifted. So non-threats will turn into threats when you are anxious. >> Over a period of time, your brain's network start changing. >> Right? So chronic stress directly leads to physical shrinkage of certain parts of the brain. So one of them is the hippocampus that is responsible for long-term memory formation.
(1:03:27) Um so people with long-term stress can have brain fog. They might start forgetting names. They might forget what was said to them a day before. Um there's another part called as the DLPFC which is a part of the prefrontal cortex that is responsible for future planning uh executive functions. So somebody with long-term anxiety can have trouble deciding, >> right? So if you ask them that, hey, what are you doing next Thursday? Do you want to meet at 9:00 a.m.? I don't know.
(1:03:54) Don't ask me that. I don't know what I'll be doing 9:00 a.m. Uh next week is too far. Ask me on Wednesday. Right? >> Right? Because the simple act of trying to think that far ahead is too stressful because that brain part is now shrinking. That can lead to depression. >> Right. >> Because eventually an inability to do these basic functions will lead them to think badly about themselves.
(1:04:16) >> Right. >> And all these people are probably high achieving people before. >> Yeah. >> Because that's the thing with stress. When stress is increasing, there is a zone where stress is optimum. >> That's the optimum zone of stress. and they perform really well at that time and so they've probably done very good at school and college but the stress keeps increasing and then they switch over to excessive stress that's when they go into anxiety panic and now their identity doesn't match with what they're seeing in front of them.
(1:04:45) >> So there's this whole other loop that kicks in. >> So all of these are stories that play out over 5 10 years >> and the recovery would also mean that you're reversing all of this. >> Yes. >> Right. Right. So, it's not going to be a one week course of medication. It would actually be pretty intensive therapy.
(1:05:03) Um, working on your physical health, working on your mental health. The good thing is that it will not take as long to recover as it did to form. Like I would say that it's 10% of the time it took you to get there, you can probably get back if you are in treatment properly. >> So, if it took you 10 years to get there, you know, like 10 months for example, I'm just saying.
(1:05:26) But yeah, like a few months of good therapy will help you come out of it. >> So it's not like holiday weight gain which comes on [laughter] quickly but takes a long time to >> No, it's not that. No, because our brain thankfully is neuroplastic. >> It it brain and our body I really do feel the more patients I treat, I'm in awe.
(1:05:42) >> Yeah, it's fascinating >> of this system, right? It has such an incredible capacity to heal >> if you just give it that environment. >> Yeah. But expecting it to heal while still being in an environment that is actively harming it >> is asking for too much. >> Okay. Because art is such an important part of our lives and you spoke so passionately about art as well.
(1:06:04) One of the things that I missed asking then was about art therapy also which is really used and we've spoken about it again um with some psychiatrists and psychologists who've been on the show um not just for children but for also for adults >> and it made me think about my child also when she was young one of the first things that people said to do with her was to take her to music classes and to art classes for her development and for the development of her brain.
(1:06:32) >> Yeah. Um, and I wanted to ask again the both of you a little bit about that connection uh between art and the brain and what it actually does >> uh to our brains and why babies react to music in the way that they do. Um whether music is another language of its own what is happening to the brain. >> Sure.
(1:06:55) So um let's talk about music because I feel that is something that people can connect to more um because art is more of a broader term. Absolutely. >> So what's interesting about music is >> every culture on earth >> has independently discovered music >> and if you think about how strange that is because music in a sense is we are using physics to vibrate something.
(1:07:18) >> Yeah. And that vibration is going through air and hitting our ears and our ear is converting that vibration into electricity >> and those electric signals are getting interpreted by the brain and suddenly we feel things. >> Yeah. >> And our bodies are moving because of that electric signals. That is what music is.
(1:07:39) >> And somehow every culture on earth has independently discovered instruments. They have their own music forms. They have their own dance forms. So clearly it is something inherent to the brain to the human brain the ability to understand music and appreciate music >> and the reason for this is that m there is no separate network in the brain for music.
(1:08:04) >> Music is built on top of a very ancient network in the brain which was used for calculating distances. like so like a bat like sound and >> like vibration. every single animal has to cross uh has to move through the world right so it is calculating distances so let's say a monkey swinging from tree to tree it has to calculate the distance from one branch to another >> so there is a part in the brain called as the cerebellum and the basil ganglia so these are two separate parts of the brain they work together to help you
(1:08:37) move >> and it is calculating how distant each part is >> in music you are calculating distances between notes And so if one beat and another beat and another beat is coming at the same frequency, our brain is calculating that okay this is the distance between each note and then our predictive algorithms kick in.
(1:09:00) >> If three beats have come in this note that means the fourth beat should come here and when that fourth beat falls on that note we get a dopamine spike >> right? >> We are we feel like we have solved a puzzle >> right? and then the fifth and the sixth. And so what music does is it gives us a sense of achievement.
(1:09:19) >> Our primitive brain feels like it has solved some very complex puzzle. >> Yeah. >> And so the more we listen to it, the happier we get >> because we're constantly predicting. >> Now add on top of beats, you add rhythm >> and you add melody and then you add words >> and then you add >> body movements which is dance.
(1:09:40) Yes, >> we are creating a multi-layer dopamine predicting algorithm. >> So we get happier and happier. That is why music is like a drug, >> right? >> Right. It is it is like a puzzle that our brain loves to solve. >> So when there's a concert and there's a song that uh you know you you really like and that song is playing and there are 10,000 people singing that same song together, >> imagine the kind of dopamine hit that you get.
(1:10:06) >> Yeah. because it's several layers of puzzles getting solved. >> I don't think that's what music is >> understood and explanation of music >> like that. But it's it's really fascinating to think about >> what is happening now. You are a musician and you're creating music. >> But do you see the science in what you're doing? How like when you put together compositions or lyrics? >> Like do you come up like do you understand the process? Do you come up with the notes? Do you come up with the lyrics? Do you think about the feeling?
(1:10:39) Like how >> it's all of it. The order can be randomized based on what I'm creating. So sometimes the melody will come to me first. And I as a side note, I really love this concept. And I've loved it since a time when I didn't have the vocabulary to describe it. Uh now the vocabulary I'm using is lent from Elizabeth Gilbert in her book Big Magic.
(1:11:01) She talks about thought forms being entities that are looking for human collaborators. >> So they are floating in a dimension which we cannot see. Uh but sometimes you just get an idea right then I will put the world on pause and I will just receive whatever's coming. It might be words in which case I'll scribble everything down.
(1:11:21) Um if it's a melody I'll just take out my voice recording app and I'll just put that. Sometimes it's so annoying. I get the best melody ideas on planes where I can't sing without like disturbing people around me. >> Um, >> you go to the bathroom. >> I do. I've done that so many times [laughter] >> or in the mi
(1:11:37) ddle at 2:00 a.m. when you're trying to sleep, but something wants to be like, "Hey, want to play?" You know? [laughter] Um, but what's really fascinating is sometimes when you don't do that, >> everything seems mechanical. >> You sit down to want to create music and you don't get anything. >> So that writer's block is a real thing.
(1:11:54) >> It It is. It is um same thing in music as well. Sometimes you just you're sitting there in a session and you're like, "Okay, let's let's create a beat or you just don't get any right ideas at that time." And it's best to just call it quits that day and come back when you're inspired or bring those little voice notes or melodies or lyrics that you had and then come together and collaborate because for me the joy is in collaboration through music rather than like an isolation um you know lonely exercise which I do
(1:12:23) for my sad songs. You know you said sad um and happy. So, is it that when you're sad, you sit down and you write? And how is it possible to make art when you're happy? Because aren't you aren't you too busy like being happy? Uh, for me, it makes me even happier. So, the point I was trying to make was what something really fascinating happens with sad music.
(1:12:48) So, when I was like 11 years old or 10 years old, I didn't know what heartbreak was. And I didn't >> Yeah. >> I mean, >> I did I personally didn't. My sister took my orange candy and I was really heartbroken. >> That was heartbre. I mean in terms of romantic relationships I was extremely >> kind of as a mother of 9year-old. I'm saying you're way too young.
(1:13:06) >> Yeah. Yeah. Exactly. >> I mean I had friends who were going through romantic relationships in sixth grade and seventh grade and >> I was happening earlier now. >> Yes. Don't talk to me. That's another podcast. I'm not [laughter] interested in my podcast right now. We talk for another time.
(1:13:21) Like the point was I'm listening to an adult song >> and I am crying my eyes out even though I don't know what the hell she's talking about >> right and I have not >> it's the violin and the piano and it's like >> no her songs are actually just again piano ballads most of them there are some in which there are orchestras but typically it's just her voice >> and her story and to me I was listening to what she was saying and the way her voice was breaking on certain notes and I could tell part of it is empathy right you're feeling the pain of the other
(1:13:50) person. Part of it actually this is the most fascinating thing scientifically is it's a rehearsal of pain. >> Yes. >> So before you know what heartbreak is, you are rehearsing it through this person's narrative such that and this is the coolest thing when you go through an eventual first heartbreak, you have resilience to deal with it because you've rehearsed it through song.
(1:14:09) >> You have immunity. >> Yeah. >> Isn't that crazy? >> It's amazing. >> So I I have a lot of friends who turn off a sad song immediately as it comes on because they're like, "No, I'm sad. I'm sad. I don't like being sad >> but there is you need to go through that to build your strength and resilience and also more than that I see these are the boys all the boys >> who do this they don't want to tap into their sadness they want to feel good all the time they want their Punjabi pop songs on all the time [laughter] right
(1:14:35) or or their Drake on all the time >> but that you you need to tap into that world >> and that's why they can't handle rejection and that's why we have so much male talk >> so her has been dying to talk about gender differences [laughter] yeah about We need men to listen to sad songs so they can be better people >> and understand >> and and also just better more in tune with themselves.
(1:14:55) >> Absolutely. So I I don't shy away from making sad songs. Uh so your initial >> is this a promotional plug for your next sad song >> which is coming out tomorrow. >> It just so happens [laughter] it just so happens that Chad which was a song I journaled about to be honest I I was writing right I was talking about journaling.
(1:15:14) So in my on my birthday this is 10th Jan 2024 I was in Chandigar and I used to have the best birthdays in London and here I am at my parents house and my mom's like ready right and that's the only plan we have for the day that I have to go and feed cows at the gshala which I love to do and I love going to the mandr but that's about it and I'm like I used to start my day at Harold Ste room with like you know [laughter] >> and then I skating and then >> I'm going to write a sad song.
(1:15:38) >> No literally I was experiencing my first heartbreak at that time coincidentally. So I was like, I'm coming. I'm coming. And I used to like want to pretend to be strong in front of my parents, right? They already had had told me three years ago, this guy is not for you. And I had gone through three years of like trying to convince them, no, no, this is the one. Right.
(1:15:57) So eventually when that didn't work out, I'm like, now I can't be sad in front of them. They're going to tell me I'm an idiot. And I'm wasting further time being sad over. >> They told you for three years. >> Exactly. So I used to hide and cry. So I was [laughter] I was writing in my journal. I have so many questions playing on repeat on my mind.
(1:16:12) Why did you do this? Why did you leave me? How did you give up on us so easily? Right? And then all of a sudden I'm like playing this blues track while I'm writing this and I get a melody >> and that becomes the hook and that's a Punjabi thing. >> Uh Punjabi hook. So then I turned that piece that I was just talking about into my verse and now that's a song.
(1:16:30) I didn't think I would ever release it. Uh but I've noticed that I performed it live in my first show in Chandigar and that was the stickiest one. And making happy songs makes me much happier because dopamine how it works is you're anticipating happiness. When I'm going to the studio, I already know I'm going to have a great time.
(1:16:46) Especially if it's a friend of mine that I'm working with who I love working with. So the anticipation of dopamines. He plays me an afro beat. I'm like flying. Right. Then we have a sticky composition on top of that. I'm like, how much further can we take this? And honestly, in my experience so far, the furthest you can take it is when you're performing for an audience and they're all feeling that to your point and you're done.
(1:17:06) You're jumping on stage. That's what you were saying. And then like you know you take that and then you have a crowd of people singing your chorus. >> Yeah. And it's a it's a different kind of >> that's the highest form of dopamine ecstasy that you can possibly feel as a musician. >> Yeah. >> It is ecstasy.
(1:17:22) I think chemically it is it would be the same chemical composition as what an ecstasy pill would be because it's adrenaline, dopamine, serotonin. You are actually getting all of that when you're on stage because and also a bit of oxytocin which exercise doesn't have. So it's like a really powerful uh drug >> drug healthiest form >> healthiest form of Yes. Absolutely.
(1:17:43) >> And this is what I mean actually I suppose drugs are needed when you're not able to get that from your daily life. Um perhaps because you've been numbed by a bunch of other things including that iPad um and too much technology. Lots of things I wanted to just touch on. art being fabulous in terms of society as well. Yeah.
(1:18:03) Just because I've seen I mean you know we have examples all over the world um from your Picassos and your gernikas to like Rubind to go in India recent I mean I was a part of a movie called Rang Basanti which became more than a movie it became a movement I mean it's not >> any [laughter] we loved you in that this will also be cut out but I'm just saying that >> I have to tell you something.
(1:18:25) So when I was in MBBS um we actually booked an entire theater and 120 students from Grand Medical College went to see that movie and we were all crying and shouting and screaming and that was probably the most >> because you liked it so much. >> We loved it. We loved it. We have never experienced anything like that.
(1:18:45) I never thought I would get a chance to tell you this. >> We'll keep all of this. We'll keep all of this. [laughter] >> This is incredible. But I it's it's a core memory for me. It's a core memory of my life. And you were so good. >> Thank you. Thank you. But I mean now I've lost my what was my question? My question was about art and change and um how like I just feel like a lot of people don't think about it so much.
(1:19:06) Art is now like you know we've had recent protests where we've just talked about how people have used art as self-expression. Um both of you I wanted to ask I mean in terms of how you feel it can impact society where do you think about like the societal impact of your work how to give back like do these things cross your mind >> absolutely that's the reason why I quit my full-time job actually so I was working in behavioral science for public health basically what I realized through my job as well and all the studying I
(1:19:33) had done was okay so behavioral science is trying to change people's beliefs if I have to summarize in one statement >> because when you change someone's beliefs is when you change their behavior Yeah. >> Now, how do you change people's beliefs? Everything that I described about like a randomized control trial, etc.
(1:19:48) , etc., are great intellectual ways to think about a problem and to solve for real world problems. >> But people don't respond so well to statistics, science, and rationale as they do sometimes to feeling. Yes. >> So, stories can change minds, but oh, sorry. Uh, statistics can change minds, and that's what we try with social sciences, but stories change hearts really quickly.
(1:20:12) And you you were talking about how music is central to all cultures >> and it's a really underressearched area. >> Last year I was working on an assignment for the World Bank on edutainment. They were calling it edutainment. Um educating people through entertainment. >> I know. I have a 9-year-old. That's all she's allowed to is edutainment.
(1:20:29) >> Yeah. So and and it's still relatively a newer subsection of where behavioral science is getting applied. and I would love to be in that and I'm trying to be in that because it's the bridge for all of my interests. But it's so true that very quickly if a person relates to uh what we call narrative transportation like if they're watching a piece of cinema that was created to change their behavior but they don't know that they just they're getting entertained through a character and their journey in their life. Um if they're relating to that
(1:20:57) character they're automatically glued and clicked in clicked on and you guide them through that journey. At the end that character makes a choice. Unconsciously or subconsciously you have been primed to make the same choice. And because you resonated with them and you were embedded transported into that narrative now your heart and your belief has changed a little bit.
(1:21:15) We are not able to do that so effectively and quickly and through these I will say clever mechanisms when we are teaching them or educating them through a poster workshop or a a guided seminar we simply can't. So it's really fascinating how music can be used as a tool >> for power of art. >> Yeah. For societal change in Virginia.
(1:21:35) >> Because when we talk of men and women, there is a huge >> finally [laughter] >> huge section of impact that art has had on the way that men and women are. So far more than fundamental hormone differences or brain differences, I would say that the environment that a child grows up in has had the maximum impact on the way that a man behaves or a woman behaves.
(1:22:07) So every time you see a movie where the main male character is behaving in a certain way and they are being really cool and a child is seeing that and wants to be like that their brain is learning that if I have to be cool these other things are part of my personality. No child is born with a massochistic streak or a mis misogynistic streak or um violent streak.
(1:22:36) It's these are all learned >> through life experiences. So art has a if art can do harm, it can also do good. >> So it's great that there is a push back there is there's art that is aimed at healing. And art therapy is that. >> Yes. >> Right. Art therapy allows you or rather art therapy allows your subconscious brain to bring out things that it otherwise did not have any means to.
(1:23:02) >> Yeah. And all those thoughts, emotions, feelings were just trapped inside >> and art sort of opens a back door. >> Yes. >> And all those things come out and that is the only way that your conscious brain can see it. >> So there are so many people who will sit in therapy and say there's nothing wrong with me.
(1:23:22) And you ask them to draw and they draw the most horrific images and then they see it and they and then we ask them that okay what is this? and you realize that oh they've drawn a picture of themselves in a house with full cages right >> where everything is trapped and they see and that's how they see themselves and the first five minutes is all about no there's nothing wrong >> because your prefrontal cortex refuses to allow yourself that vulnerability but in art it's difficult to lie >> right because lying is a language thing >> it's very difficult to lie with your
(1:23:56) body >> it's very difficult to lie with your music, >> it's difficult to lie with your sketching or your painting because we haven't learned. >> We've only learned to lie with our words, >> right? >> So, you use any other form of language, the truth will come out >> and that's how you see it. So, that's how art is so useful in therapy.
(1:24:15) Interesting. So, as as a neurologist, I have not um ever gone into this um theater art world until recently. Last year I took a oneweek acting workshop simply out of curiosity and um it changed my life honestly. It changed the way that I look at the brain because I realized how much you can absorb a reality and make it your own.
(1:24:41) M so when you're doing an acting workshop um I don't have to tell this crowd but I'm just I I realized that as a bad actor I would read the lines and at the end of the workshop the last day I had a certain script and I had to simply create what they called they called it something there was just one line that you keep repeating yourself to kind of ingrain that character in you >> and then at one point you believe that you are that character and then the script doesn't matter anymore you just go and say whatever you want to say, but
(1:25:10) you're saying it as that character, >> right? >> And it works. I saw the video later. It wasn't me. I was I was somebody else. >> So your brain is capable of creating an alternate identity if you allow it. >> Yeah. >> So reverse engineering that >> you can make a person experience a different identity. >> Yes.
(1:25:32) >> And then sort of guide them >> Yes. >> towards in that direction. >> Yes. It has absolutely changed the way I I think art should be um mandatory for everybody >> which also so sorry I don't want to keep >> yeah I'm [laughter] sorry sorry I think this is howation should go >> it's so relevant and topical because look at what just happened recently politically in our country >> polarization is at an all-time high worldwide not just in India right people are not willing to participate in open conversations about this can be your
(1:26:06) truth and simultaneously mine can exist. So this as a workshop of embodying a different character is so necessary for us to build that muscle of empathy. >> Yes. So then it's about understanding that people are different and that comes from something. Nobody is you know and then when you understand where it comes from you're able to have a dialogue I think even if you're not convinced by the other person but at least you agree to disagree as opposed to you know not even being able to do that.
(1:26:33) >> Yeah. And to come back to your earlier point of why the human story becomes so um convincing for somebody, that's the whole format of having two people on the podcast is to have somebody who is an expert who brings the statistics, >> but somebody who's been touched by a story to make it more digestible, I think, and more it sort of stays with you in in some way, which helps that process change.
(1:26:57) >> Um >> I think that brings us almost towards the end of this. M >> um was anything you want to say about the female brain being more superior because I prompted you [laughter] so many times >> and you have not. >> I I was saving it for the for the Yes. So because I feel of course it is superior.
(1:27:15) How can I [laughter] >> I'll just make that check out to our doctor >> um to to be >> okay just the differences. Is it just hormones? >> Hormones play a role >> and hormones like change us. >> It does, >> right? >> It definitely does. So to okay so this whole conversation has gone through a big roller coaster over the last few decades >> right um because there was a time when um oh this is just hormonal was a dismissal.
(1:27:44) >> Yes. >> And it almost felt like an insult. >> Yes. >> Right. And so naturally no one would want to be insulted and so there was an entire dismissal of the whole hormone conversation. Now I think what is happening is that our understanding of hormones and receptors and how the brain works is much more.
(1:28:06) I feel that dismissing hormones is sort of invalidating the ex lived experience of so many women. Hormones definitely affect the way that a brain functions. Whether that's estrogen progesterone in women, whether that's testosterone in men, women have testosterone too and men have estrogen too. It's just the ratios that are different and the fluctuations of these hormones affects the way that you think affects your mood.
(1:28:34) So there are so many women who will experience a different mood at the beginning of their period period cycle whereas say after ovulation the next 15 days is a very different kind of mood. >> Yes. Now there is a reason for that because estrogen is a pro-dopamine hormone >> and after ovulation estrogen drops progesterone is still high and that combination has a unique effect on the prefrontal cortex whereas wherein progesterone blocks the dopamine receptors from getting activated.
(1:29:07) So what women um experience as PMS is basically dopamine not being able to do its function in the prefrontal cortex. So they may feel lack of motivation. They may feel tired. Now to not acknowledge this is to say that this is all just your conscious decision. >> You are choosing to do this. That's not fair at any level.
(1:29:35) So in fact I feel that once you understand the variability life should be structured taking this variability into account. >> That is what is ideal. The reason that it is not is because the structure was designed by men who did not go through that cycle. >> Right. >> Right. So if you create straight lines for um a car that is circular the car will always seem out of place.
(1:30:01) >> Right. But it is simply the structure that was built not keeping this in mind. Right? >> So the reason that I feel women struggle in this system is because it is not built for them. And so only by acknowledging this will we start rebuilding that system. >> Absolutely. And you know in my gym routine I've I've now factored in my period into that in terms of the kind of workout I do, the kind of rest that I give myself.
(1:30:28) you know, you know, when like ovulation happens, you feel like a sense of energy and it's real >> and so behaving differently, eating different foods at different times of the cycle, um, exercising differently because exercise is one of the strongest modulators of progesterone. So if you do understand your body and you if you figure out that okay this is the time when I will uh out but this is the time when I will just get in my 10,000 steps and this is the time when I will just do my basic stuff just stretching nothing too crazy >> and following that cycle
(1:31:02) >> it would lead to your brain being protected >> right >> but for that this conversation needs to happen right like that acknowledgement has to be there >> yeah um again as we and unless there's something else that you want to say as we come towards the end of this I thought I would ask you if you could um address some people are watching and tell them perhaps a real doable way that they could >> catch a bad decision that they're perhaps >> about to make before they start actually making it.
(1:31:29) [laughter] >> Uh yeah. No, sure. So I think I mentioned system one, system two, but I didn't describe what they are. So in the book thinking fast and slow and what Daniel Conman uh won the Nobel Prize for was research into these two sort of mental models. So the first is system one which is autopilot.
(1:31:46) We're making our choice about you know when you're putting your shoes on, you're driving on autopilot, you're receiving phone calls, you're almost texting on autopilot as well these days. But if we ask you what is 34 * 46, you're going to have to sit down and do the math. Um that is system two, the deliberative logical uh reasoning side of things.
(1:32:05) So I think to catch yourself from making a bad decision, it it often for me happens from a place of autopilot thinking. um and intuition and not in the wrong side. Intuitive I perhaps the better word is impulsive. >> Yes. >> Making an impulsive choice uh because I'm fatigued because I'm in the wrong context because I am actually reflecting what people around me believe versus having had a moment to sit and think about how I feel.
(1:32:30) So the first thing to do is take a beat, take a pause, breathe >> and then ask yourself what am I feeling right now? And this is where emotions are uh considered your navigational guidance system. If you're feeling anxious, it's for a reason. It's your body trying to tell you something. If you're feeling pain somewhere, it's for a reason.
(1:32:50) So just tap in and ask what am I feeling right now? What is an assumption that I'm working on right now? That's the second question. >> Um and third is what evidence can I look for to challenge that assumption? If you do these three things, you will catch yourself from making a bad decision and you would have activated the critical thinking brain.
(1:33:08) >> Uh which will question what is the assumption? Where is it coming from? >> What in terms of the third question, what evidence am I looking for? It could be a conversation with someone who believes differently. >> It could be let me go online and actually search uh is this something that I've just heard? Is it fake news or where has this come from? And can I just, you know, course correct my thinking real quick.
(1:33:30) Um, I think that if you follow that three-step think, you are probably not going to make the wrong decision. And then let's layer the gut thing on top of that. Sometimes having done all of this, you're still not convinced >> and you're like, there's something within me just saying no. >> Then just don't make a decision. Don't make a decision in that moment.
(1:33:45) Give yourself more time. >> We are so wired to be turned on and quickly making all these decisions that >> there's no rush, you know? No, nothing's going to happen if you just sleep on it. >> Right. I think that's important because now in this double take generation, you want somebody to respond immediately. Um, I think it's good also to train people not you don't respond to them.
(1:34:04) They also have to learn to be patient and wait for your response. You know, >> my mother still insists on writing letters to my daughter and um and then they wait for you know the few days and speed post that it takes to come here because today we expect an answer immediately like I'm like why are you writing her letter? >> But they they keep this the cycle going.
(1:34:20) It helps the writing as well but it also just teaches you to wait. That's beautiful. >> And to be patient. >> That's really >> I've seen a couple of um things that you've said on a real about 2026 and ways to have a better functioning brain. >> I think that people are interested in having a better functioning brain.
(1:34:37) So you've talked about >> early morning walks and sunlight >> and better breathing. >> Yes. >> Is anything else you want to add to that in terms of and also you can expand on the breathing. Breathing obviously important but a way of breathing [laughter] >> and um >> why these things are good. >> Yeah.
(1:34:54) I think I can continue from where you left off because um all bad decisions in general come from a place of um anxiety. >> Yeah. >> Where you feel like you are in danger and you need to make something quickly. You you need to make a decision quickly. >> Yes. >> So that is called as a sympathetic or hyperympathetic state where you are in fight or flight.
(1:35:17) Now as soon as you go into fight or flight your prefrontal cortex gets shut off. So your liyic system takes over and says I I'm going to decide because I am in danger right now. >> Right? >> Most bad decisions come when you are in that state of mind. So the reason that learning to breathe is so important is because we go into a sympathetic state far more than we realize.
(1:35:39) >> Right? So every time we get a phone call or every time your boss texts you or every time you're late, you are going into sympathetic. So we are living in a life that is designed to constantly keep you in a hyper sympathetic state. >> Yeah. >> Breathing is the easiest and most efficient way of keep to keep you coming back into the opposite which is the parasympathetic state.
(1:36:05) That is when you are rested calm and when you're in parasympathetic your prefrontal cortex comes back online. >> Now you can think about the consequences of your decision. That is the only one of the best ways of minimizing bad decisions. Right? So if you keep coming back to parasympathetic, wait until you are calm before executing a decision.
(1:36:29) >> Um your chances of making mistakes will reduce. Now there is a possibility that even after you are calm, your prefrontal cortex is still not online, >> right? >> You're still not or you're not sure, >> right? That is the beauty of the human brain that you can simply outsource your decision- making to somebody else's prefrontal cortex.
(1:36:50) So if I am going through a lifethreatening situation and you are standing in front of me, your prefrontal cortex is online because >> I'm >> you are not threatened. >> Yeah. I'm a little detached from the situation. >> Yes. So I can simply put this question to you >> and if I trust that you have my best interest at heart, I can trust your prefrontal cortex to make a decision for me >> until I am back in parasympathetic until my PFC is back.
(1:37:19) >> Saying have a conversation with somebody who absolutely perhaps give you >> absolutely so this is what therapy is. This is what talking to a friend is. This is what talking to yourself is. journaling is >> so in a way you're simply outsourcing your decision making to a better prefrontal cortex >> right >> ultimately some PFC has to decide >> right >> if it's not your own then it is somebody else's >> right >> and the only way to get your own PFC to decide is to get back into parasympathetic >> right >> right and when you I think the most
(1:37:48) important thing for all of us is to understand are you in sympathetic or parasympathetic right now >> I think this is a life skill >> that all of us from childhood should learn because it is so subtle the signs are so subtle when we are going into sympathetic you know you you get a little restless >> I was going to ask you if you can just tell us some signs to to identify >> so you can keep track of your eyes I think eyes are a great tool if your eyes are flicking all over the place you are going into sympathetic
(1:38:18) >> you are breathing faster >> I'm linking eyes with you [laughter] >> so then you are clearly in parasite but if you're breathing breathing faster. If you can check your pulse or if you can simply be aware of your heart rate, >> it is a very very sensitive sign of sympathetic versus parasympathetic. If your heart rate is 50, you're good.
(1:38:37) >> Yeah. >> If your heart rate is 100, 120, 150, then you are going into sympathetic. Right. >> Right. So, just being aware of that and learning to bring it down. Your body is fidgeting. Be aware of your thoughts. If more and more of your thoughts are negative, if you feel that bad things will happen, that is a sign of sympathetic state >> because it's not reality.
(1:39:00) It's just that your mind can only see negative outcomes, >> right? >> So somewhere you have to question that, wait, my life isn't that bad, >> right? >> Why am I only thinking of bad outcomes, >> right? >> You're insetic, >> right? >> Calm down. Learn to breathe. >> That's why breathing is such a important tool, >> right? >> Cuz you you have it with you all the time.
(1:39:17) >> Yeah. It's three deep long breaths, >> exhale slowly, hum if you can >> and you are back in parasympathetic. >> Yeah. Amazing. Amazing. >> I wanted to ask something if you >> you've been talking a lot about the prefrontal cortex, right? From a neurosense mapping fMRI or just other forms of imaging perspective.
(1:39:36) Is there such a thing as a healthier looking PFC? Like can you actually see when someone's PFC is >> healthier than normal? uh there are a few ways of identifying when it is not healthy >> because a healthy PFC is one that has great connectivity >> with specifically the singulate cortex. Um so it's interesting.
(1:39:58) So the lyic system is the emotional brain. The prefrontal cortex is the evolved brain. In the middle of these is a part called as the singulate cortex which is kind of like a referee. >> Right? So if there is a conflict between your emotional brain and your logical brain, your anti- singulate cortex steps in and says okay let's go with this guy.
(1:40:17) >> Nice >> now. The stronger your singulate cortex is the more disciplined you are. >> Right? >> Or vice versa, the more disciplined you are, the stronger your single cortex is. >> So if you have a strong PFC single cortex connectivity, that means that you are more likely to be able to say no to your >> emotional um impulses.
(1:40:37) Whereas if that connectivity is weak, you are more likely to go for just >> how do we strengthen the connectivity? >> By consistently doing hard things. >> Yeah. Building up that resilience. >> Yeah. And so what is hard for you is subjective to you. >> So you don't have to go for a marathon tomorrow, but can you do 5,000 steps? >> Right? >> If that's hard for you, because it is very subjective to your brain, >> right? >> So whatever is hard for you, try and do that.
(1:41:08) And that is how you increase that connectivity. And every 1 month maybe increase it by 10%. >> Yeah, >> that's it. That's all you have to do. But the earlier you start doing this, >> the more prepared your brain is, the more resilient your brain is. So if kids have been brought up with a lot of comfort and the first time they see a challenge is when they are preparing for their neat exam, their brain can get simply overwhelmed by the amount of stress.
(1:41:31) >> Yeah. And now parents would feel that oh I have to protect my child through all of childhood. I need to give them all the comfort in the world. I'm not sure that's a good thing. >> No. >> Right. Because you have to train them just like you train their body. Yes. >> You have to train their mind.
(1:41:44) But it has to be done in a way that is >> just what is hard. >> Yeah. >> Not toxic. It just has to be hard. That's it. >> The good thing is the brain takes care of itself. >> You don't have to get it absolutely right. There's nothing like absolutely right. I don't think there's an absolutely perfect parent. As long as you love them and give keep them safe, I the brain does take care of itself.
(1:42:05) I'm a neurooptimist. >> I I really do believe that. I feel we don't have to worry too much. >> Yeah. >> Um except some obviously harmful things like 2-year-olds should not be scrolling ress. >> Yeah. >> But other than that, um if you've given them enough exploration, >> if they have enough experiences, wide variety of experiences of success and failure.
(1:42:26) >> Yes. really important that kids have to fail. >> Yes. >> So important that kids have to fail and that's why sports is so great because >> they fall they you know they fail they lose matches. >> It's important more than success they should experience failure and bouncing back >> so that their brain at least knows that aa this is possible this is reality.
(1:42:48) >> If you don't experience that uh it's a problem. No, I think that's a great lesson for at least parents who are watching this and for me, it may be hard to watch your child fail. But in that's the short-term thing. The long-term impact of that is only going to be beneficial. >> Absolutely. Absolutely. >> And when we talk about it in terms of physical health, it's so intuitive.
(1:43:09) >> We never feel bad when a child is unable to lift 10 kgs, but he can lift 2 kgs. >> You don't feel bad. You know that 2 kg will lead to 3 kg later, >> right? And when the child is trying to lift 3 kg, you'll encourage it. But if he fails, you won't take it personally. >> No. >> But somehow when it comes to mental things, >> yeah, >> we believe that all failure is >> final.
(1:43:33) >> Is final, >> right? And I believe that's because we are sort of projecting our own anxiety. But if we are now talking about all of these things and letting children make choices and fail and you know it's going to have to take a lot of >> cushioning our own pain in that way, right? >> Best thing a parent can do for their kid is to go to therapy.
(1:43:56) >> They have to go to therapy, take care of their own anxiety because they're carrying >> pass that baggage on >> to a future generation. >> Absolutely. >> Because as you said, theirs is a clean slate. >> So >> correct. >> Yeah. Final question. Uh just because we started with bad decisions, I wanted to ask if there's a decision that both of you are proud of having made >> against your gut instinct.
(1:44:18) >> Against my gut instinct. O um so this was a very old one though. >> This was this happened when I was in school. >> Okay. >> Um so I wanted to become a musician >> and Yeah. Yeah. So I had a I had I had a bunch of songs written. I had given the music. I used to play the piano a little bit.
(1:44:43) I thought I'll make a band and all of that stuff. >> And my dad's a doctor, my mom's a music teacher. So I literally felt like okay, I have to pick between one of those. Again, being from India, you don't see laterality. You feel like it's either A or B. >> And I my gut was telling me that, oh, music is where my heart or art is where my heart is.
(1:45:06) But I felt like I was curious about science and so I literally had to choose one and I decided okay I'll I'll I'll do this and um it wasn't until very recently that that circle got completed for me. I'm proud that I did that because now I realized that art is in everything. >> Yeah. So I'm not sure if I would have realized that science isn't everything if I had taken art.
(1:45:35) >> But after having gone through all of neuroscience and understood this, I've now come to the realization that there is art. There's so much art in medicine. >> There's so much art in practicing medicine and the way you talk to patients and it's like it's it's like it's like theater. >> It's like a performance almost.
(1:45:51) >> Um so I'm I'm glad that I did that. >> We can still release your songs if you wish. >> Yeah, there you [laughter] go. That's the right people. >> That's that would be that would be quite >> and also it's never it's never too late. >> It's never too late. Absolutely. >> And that is what is so wonderful like I I didn't even know how close music was um as a part of your life before this and you know these are things that and you think that these are exclusive things completely science and art but they're but they're really not.
(1:46:17) >> What about you? >> Mine is an interesting one because I really am protective of this whole like follow your gut instinct >> for reasons that we've discussed. But perhaps I can speak to more of what feels right as a girl sometimes to do. Uh that being almost let's say proxy for gut. >> Yes. >> Um I'm proud and this might sound like a frivolous example but I have a tendency and I've noticed a lot of my friends who are girls have it too and we have gotten it from our mothers who have gotten it from theirs. um to always please the
(1:46:49) other person in a relationship or to stay in a relationship that might not be making us happy but to have a complete inability to see that it makes us unhappy. >> We constantly see the positive. We are optimists in that. Um and I'm very happy that I didn't repeat the same mistake twice because >> there's this there there's also a related concept in art where you kind of touched on it that we think it comes from pain.
(1:47:17) So when I have fallen in love for the second time so far in my life, I'm like this makes me this is not a good dynamic for me. I'm not getting my needs met or this is not what I want. But I love this person. And my tendency which is the proxy for gut was to stay and to to keep giving the way I give even in the absence of receiving what I needed.
(1:47:38) >> Um and I used to convince myself that that pain and longing was really good for art. that that's how I was writing better songs. >> Yeah. And this is this is a myth that exists even among actors and you know a lot of a lot of musicians of any uh type like you could be an instrumental >> torment the soul must be in torment >> or a visual artist. Yeah.
(1:47:59) We and and there is some truth to that. I won't lie. Uh but don't subject yourself to it endlessly. There's enough pain as a woman you have to endure anyway >> to please save yourself the misery [laughter] >> of that. So, I'm I'm glad that I made that uh decision to pick myself and I feel sad that I even have to glorify that >> and that that's not the obvious choice because for a man it would be >> it's this is not what I want.
(1:48:24) This is I'm not getting what I want. So, I'm not going to pick this. But we are we almost glamorize the battle >> of we want what we can't have and but like I'll be better. I'll do more. >> Right. And I'll change him. >> Oh yeah. That's Oh my god. I hate that one. So glad I didn't do that instead. You know something my dad said uh really shifted my perspective.
(1:48:44) He was like listen whatever love you're feeling for this person is actually within you. >> The guy is just a stimulus for it uh he's reflecting your own beauty back to you. Just recognize that it's within you and just treat him like a stimulus. He's there. It's great. He's not. There are other stimuli to activate that.
(1:49:04) The most important one is the relationship you have with yourself. pour that love inward and um that has been a a difficult lesson and I and one that I wish more girls would decide but that's lovely um and it was uh so nice because I didn't actually see where this conversation was going to go and it was nice because we spoke about the brain and how we can why we behave the way we do why we make certain decisions how we can change that and also more importantly I think just how art um as artists and I think all three of us are artists here as well um
(1:49:40) can use that in our respective professions. Um so I thought it was really enlightening and thank you for taking out the time um and just being on on the show. >> Thank you so much for having us. Such a pleasure to talk. >> Really it really was. Every day we spend so much time trying to understand the world around us.
(1:50:00) But perhaps the most fascinating thing that we'll ever understand is actually ourselves. It's kind of deep, but today really reminded us that our choices aren't random and our habits are not permanent and our brains are actually far more adaptable than we often give them credit for. And I think that is the most optimistic, hopeful takeaway of all.
(1:50:22) No matter where we are today, we have the ability to learn, to unlearn, and to grow. I do want to thank both of our guests for sharing their expertise um and their perspectives. And if this conversation made you at home pause, question a habit or simply understand yourself a little better, then I think that we today have set out what we wanted to do.
(1:50:43) Thank you for watching and we will see you in the next episode of All About Home.

No comments:

Post a Comment